26 Comments
User's avatar
Kerry H Pechter's avatar

So the Chinese treasury creates the yuan wealth of the Chinese elite, and they game the system by trying to convert that wealth to a more desirable currency without taking a big haircut. How does a country (like US or China) write an effective tax code if the wealthy game it? A modern sovereign (arguably) spends (as directed by elected representatives), in effect, by advancing de novo money (to citizens, employees or vendors) against the anticipated receipt of taxes. If so, then to shirk or avoid taxes is to interrupt or sabotage the cycle. You might even call it theft from the public. Perhaps Jack Leveler below agrees when he writes, "...when capitalism feels pressured to give up its sovereignty, to be restricted, it turns against democracy and the rule of law and even basic human rights."

Joequant's avatar

The thing is that if you want to move up to about 2-3 million USD out of Mainland China it is pretty trivial. Yeah, if you want to move several billion dollars out, it gets very, very hard, and the anti-corruption police will want a word with you. I don't think this is a bad thing. I mean one of the questions people will have if you are moving billions of dollars out is "hey, are you *SURE* that money is yours".

Joequant's avatar

For example if you have a company that is worth several billion dollars, I would bet that some of that cash belongs to other shareholders, and you can't just write yourself a check and move to London (which is what happened in Russia)

Jack Leveler's avatar

Great stuff. A couple of hot takes:

If capitalism is the unrestricted flow and private accumulation of sovereign or "free market" capital then China's political-economy, restricting capital, holding the sovereignty of the state over that of capital, what people are calling now "political capitalism," is at the very least showing the world that "capitalists without capitalism," or capital restrictions, can better facilitate economic growth and collective prosperity.

I'd also contend that it also exposes in relief, back home, or in the US anyway, that when push comes to shove capitalism opposes state sovereignty and democracy. Or, at the very least, exposes the lie that economic liberalism, sovereign capital, always promotes social liberalism.

If nothing else, Trump 2-- yes, not unlike the fascists in the '20s and '30s--shows us that when capitalism feels pressured to give up its sovereignty, to be restricted, it turns against democracy and the rule of law and even basic human rights.

As aways thanks for the work you do.

CJ's avatar

Rosa Luxemburg recognized that capitalism doesn't need democracy over a century ago.

Akren's avatar

Neither point is new analysis but both points are good real examples/connections for old analysis.

Msnthrop's avatar

It interesting to see the upward trend of US views toward China, though it is still quite bad (27% positive). Could it be that the number one Chinese goal, domestic stability ( as evidenced by "overcapacity", or just make sure people have a job), is also the goal of many Americans, and that a strong move toward that goal is putting a leash on the wealthy and limiting the ongoing financialization of American society?

https://www.pewresearch.org/chart/sr_26-04-00_viewsofchina_line/

Harm Roelant's avatar

Many thanks for the great post as always! Just riffing on what you wrote, if the whole principle of the CCP's project is to maintain sovereignty also in a geopolitical sense, linking the largest pools of Chinese capital to the American AI story (with all its reported positive spillovers for intelligence and military use) through reforming the capital account, would be highly unappealing.

Joequant's avatar

Also I wrote a comprehensive response to the article.

https://joequant.substack.com/p/going-through-chartbook-455

The thing that I want to note is that everyone in the article that got quote is on the other side of the world from China, and they seem to me to be getting things very, very wrong.

Joequant's avatar

If you want to move money across the border to pay CNY into a brokers account in Mainland and they will move USD/HKD into your HK account. The catch is if it turns out that the person you moved money for is really on a naughty list, you are fricked.

Joequant's avatar

Also people get the capital control system wrong. The way that it works is that if you have dollars you can do anything. The control is in converting CNY to have fron USD/HKD. If you want to invest overseas then you can buy the shares through a hedge fund or broker and they handle the currency conversion. Each person has a 50k USD per year quota on conversions but that turns out to be a lot of money for most people.

Edie Gassion's avatar

I wonder how much longer the free and unrestricted international flow of capital between global markets will continue? It's worth recalling that capital controls were integral to the Bretton Woods system. I suspect if the U.S government finds itself in a fiscal crisis related to the costs of funding its borrowings in the relative near term, we could see some, ahem, interesting twists and turns. If I were a foreign investor sitting on top of $13T in gains on U.S. investments, I'd personally devote a little bandwidth to the issue of repatriation.

Jeffrey L Kaufman's avatar

From the Chinese political/cultural point of view, how much of this economic policy is driven by the need of the CCP to have social stability? How much is driven by a world view that "we are still a peasant-focused society"? How much of this is driven by the axiom that social stability happens when people are employed, and we therefore are hesitant to change when youth unemployment is high? How much of this is driven by the fact that exports are now easy, and driving up domestic consumption can happen only with difficulty?

Joequant's avatar

It's actually not. So the big thing about China today is that you aren't going to get more production by moving poor peasants to sweatshops, because there are no more poor peasants. The only way people have come up with to get 4-5% growth for the next few decades is technology. So the thing that is happening is that China is going superheavy into tech.

Akren's avatar

Urbanization's already saturated to the point that some places need to actively try and promote rural/agricultural production again because... there's just not many people tending the farms, esp young people. The Hukou system is also a bit jank in this context now.

Mike Smitka's avatar

The parallels with Japan are very strong. I had worked for a Japanese bank on Wall Street in the late 1970s, so saw controls on capital outflows first-hand. (I then headed to grad school for an econ phd.) For example, Japanese life insurers were initially restricted to 5% of assets in non-yen assets; they initially bought sterling bonds, only to see the British pound appreciate sharply, putting those involved on the golden escalator to the C-suite. Of course when full controls came off it was the yen that appreciated: the yen / dollar rate went 260 to 130.

I really ought to be stocking up on RMB assets, but what I know is the auto industry and it's a bloodbath in China right now so am hesitant to buy shares in domestic players. In any case most of my wealth is tied up in TIAA-CREF plus I've not the speculative mindset.

m droy's avatar

2 thoughts (and thanks). Firstly that China seems years ahead in thinking about how to tax the rich and prevent them from just placing it all off shore.

Secondly that the real risk to China is not capital flight now, but massive capital return should they ever permit a revaluation of the currency.

Joequant's avatar

The thing about China is that tax rates on the rich are fairly low. The big thing about China is that you cannot convert wealth into political power. If you are a billionare that joins the Communist Party (and a lot of people do), then you will take orders from the govt and not be in a position to buy your way into becoming President. One thing about Chinese billionaries is that they try to either be quiet or portray themselves as socialist heros (i.e. look how many jobs I've created!!!!)

m droy's avatar

Sure - but low taxes is still a lot higher than no taxes.

You are right to emphasise that the key point in Oligarch power, not just oligarch money.

China seems to be on top of this, US and Europe seem to be underneath the oligarcs

eg's avatar

Maybe we need to get over the notion that capital controls and financial repression are dirty words much as the old Washington Consensus shibboleths against industrial policy have been abandoned as ridiculous.

Alec Pritzos's avatar

The revalue-the-yuan demand and the capital-flight risk point in opposite directions, and I'm not sure both camps see it. If Beijing actually opened the capital account, the $50T sitting in low-yield CNY deposits doesn't stay put to lift the currency, it runs for dollar assets and the RMB falls. So the same wall that holds up the export surplus is also what keeps the yuan from crashing.

Joequant's avatar

This is a great summary of Western conventional wisdom toward China. It is also completely wrong. As someone that runs a startup and helps people move money through Hong Kong with crypto, this is just wrong. What is happening is that rich Chinese are investing in local tech startups and high tech manufacturing. Also, it is in fact easy and trivial to move money out of China as long as you are not an official.

Scenarica's avatar

The two forces aren't separated by capital controls. They're connected by them. The controls that wall in $50 trillion keep the yuan cheap. The cheap yuan keeps Chinese exports competitive. The competitive exports generate the surplus. The surplus funds the supply chain that manufactures the chips that Taiwan designs and Mexico assembles and the US AI boom consumes. The capital controls don't put a wall between the two forces. They're the transformer that converts one into the other. Remove the wall and the yuan crashes upward, exports slow, the supply chain reprices, and the AI boom loses its cheapest input layer in the same quarter.

The closing question answers itself once you draw the circuit. You can't talk about currency policy without talking about financial repression because the repression IS the currency policy. And the currency policy IS the AI supply chain's price anchor. The people calling for revaluation are implicitly calling for tighter controls, higher input costs for the AI boom, and the end of the $60 trillion credit expansion that funds the factories that produce the deflation everyone is complaining about. They're asking to fix one imbalance by deepening the one that enables it.

Ebbe Munk.'s avatar

“The eurozone led by Germany and Japan ..” Japan, really?