19 Comments
User's avatar
WhoCares's avatar

Chillingly plausible – what’s more: probable. The US is on a descending path of authoritarian self-mutilation. It is no longer the leader of the free world, nor will it be any time soon. Brexit was a warning: when a democracy chooses self-harm, there is no guarantee of a corrective. Before our eyes Pax Americana is being flushed down history’s toilet, to join Pax Britannica in the septic tank of imperialism. At least the Brits had tea and biscuits on the way down. America though? It’s all guns, no butter.

The EU must pick up this mantle now – not with confrontation, but with insulation and repositioning: quietly accelerate defense autonomy, decouple critical dependencies, deepen alliances with democratic middle powers and step into the normative vacuum. Waiting for America to ‘snap out of it’ is as futile as appeasing the Tories was. Europe needs to act.

As for you Adam – it’s time to come home.

Kerry H Pechter's avatar

Most disturbing is the way tweets dominate public discourse and accelerate panic. Hard to imagine how we'll put that genie back in the bottle.

钟建英's avatar

Might the EU sanction the US for its authoritarian crackdown? How would the Western media report this if it occurred in Moscow, Beijing or Gaza?

Oh, I think we know. 🤣🤣

m droy's avatar

Well obviously they would report however the CIA organisers want them to - see Maidan or Hong Kong (Police violence that wasn't) versus Pro-Gaza peaceful demonstrations around the world (terrorists or not reported) or say the Gilet Jaune in France (protester violence which wasn't).

Which of course begs the question. Is the CIA involved? Is it still taking sides pro-Dem anti-Trump? A lot of people think so.

钟建英's avatar

Perhaps you are right, the Western mainstream media actually take instructions from the CIA. Hitherto, I just assume they are so parochial that they cannot see the double standards in their reporting. But perhaps I am naive, and your hypothesis is closer to the truth.

m droy's avatar

it is probably a bit more complex - they hire the right people because they are told who to hire and who not to. Many many people in the alternative media have been kicked out as correspondents and talking heads from mainstream media. To this day no one who criticised the war in Iraq gets on TV.

And I am sure they give a lot of assistance to news editors and reporters. Imagine going as a hack to China and being offered advice from the local spook at the embassy.

And finally there are things that editors simply will not accept. If you are in Ukraine and your write about:

Ukraine is losing

10:1 death ration Ukraine to Russia,

Brutal treatment of our proxies who get shot at if leaving the front line

Nato equipment completely outperformed by Russia modern equipment, in fact that Ukrainians prefer old Soviet kit.

UK/US facilitators and current soldiers supporting Ukraine with tech and planning

You won't get published.

(You might get published if you are in Washington and being briefed by CIA)

钟建英's avatar

Thanks, that all makes sense. It would be morally outrageous if the mainstream media deliberately misinform (which the ex-US spokesperson Matthew Miller recently acknowledged he did).

But in a way, parochialism is the worse problem. At least one knows whether one is deliberately lying, and could possibly be shamed into repenting. But if one is parochial, one is simply unaware of the hypocrisy and double standards, and remains shameless.

MC Simpson's avatar

It saddens me to read Miller’s descriptions of LA and to think people will believe him. While not without faults, this city is not a set of Balkanized neighborhoods resembling failed third-world countries. Yes, we have neighborhoods where various cultures congregate - Japan town, Korea town, China town and Latino neighborhoods with varying geographies, but Balkanized? No way. Just look at the food - Korean tacos, California rolls, fusions everywhere. This is a city of immigrants who dream of building a good life for themselves and their families, and we’re better for it. LA is the future - many cultures living peacefully together, sharing the best from each one.

I know this to be true. I moved here from Texas (a foreign country if there ever was one) well before Mr. Miller was born.

Elaine Waxer's avatar

You know the situation is dire when my husband goes to a No Kings protest with me in Dana Point, CA! Trump is preparing to declare martial law and cancel the midterm elections so he can stay in power forever.

Sheryl's avatar

The response to the demonstration in LA is in part dividing attention from the reconciliation bill now in the Senate and the ?inevitable? passage of the BBB. I am pleased to note that Newsom no longer thinks tariffs and trade agreements [sic] are the highest ranked

f & c's avatar

Wow - I hope my best friend wasn't right with his predictions about a renewed civil war in the US...

No, but seriously: it sounds as if the ideas of Stuart Hall to which you alluded in the context of your thesis that one could substitute "mugging" with "demonstrating for Palestine and against the Netanyahu- administration" to grasp the structural dynamic at hand fully applies here too... It is a rallying around a lie with scapegoats and everything you need to distract perfectly from the nonsense policies - and it is potentially lethal as one could see with Heather Heyer's death at Charlottesville... It will also deapen the chasm.

Thanks for the informative post!

Ben Court's avatar

Is the argument that widespread protests against Trump are always good for Trump because they allow him to escalate? If so, I'm not totally convinced this is true. Does that lead to an ultra-reactionary, anti-protest politics? Or a politics that also permits the escalation of the protests themselves to include more severe anti-Trump political actions?

michele surdi's avatar

you should of been in italy in 1977,they was killing the women just like the men

m droy's avatar

"Despite the fact that demonstrations associated with the BLM movement have been overwhelmingly peaceful,"

When the New York Times describes the BLM riots as mostly peaceful, it is worth while recalling how they described the J6 events as violent

In reality there was no comparison - best to assume that the NYT was making a joke that its readership would understand. Pity Adam doesn't seem to have got the joke.

Incidentally while Policing on blacks has been lighter since, Police killings of Blacks has gone up since 2020. As did the main source of murder in US, Black on Black killings.

I'm not pro-Trump particularly, but a failure to recognise where the violence is coming from makes blog pieces like this invalid.

David E Lewis's avatar

Thanks for the analysis with which I sadly agree.

On the subjects of flags and theater I've been thinking about the use of the Mexican flag by some protestors. It does make for great MAGA optics. It also plays well in Mexico as radicalizer.

Gestalt political messaging.

Dick Dorroile's avatar

That's how it's framed, but weird that when people display Ukraine flags for solidarity with Ukrainians, or Israel flags for solidarity with Israelis - it's not framed the same way as the Mexican flag for solidarity with Mexican immigrants (I could hazard a few guesses as to why).

Whatever the case, it's not like you can tell thousands of people showing up to protests to consider the optics. There's no leader directing this. So it seems more important to support the protests without considering too much of what's good or bad for MAGA optics.

Would having American flags make much of a difference? A lot of them do have American flags. As long as there's even one person with a Mexican flag, right wing media and commentators will zoom in on that and say, "Aha! They are bad guys!"

David E Lewis's avatar

I agree there is no one coordinator here. Protestors tend to come in unrelated groups.

I'm suggesting, without any direct evidence, that some of these Mexican flag wavers are doing it knowing the RW media will broadcast it widely and hoping for a different effect than a MAGA oriented person suspects.